The Three Lovers- Wiley (VA) 1914 Davis F
[From: Traditional Ballads of Virginia; Davis, 1929. His notes follow. Virginia ballad no. 19 is "Fair Margaret and Sweet William" and ballad 20 is "Lord Lovel."
R. Matteson 2014]
18. LORD THOMAS AND FAIR ANNET
(Child, No. 73)
THE three lovely ballads that follow (Nos. 18, 19, and 20) are so closely akin and so frequently blended with one another it will be well to mention their distinguishing marks in advance. All are concerned with the tragedy that follows in the wake of the betrayal or too long deferring of true love. In I8 and 19 the man loves one woman but marries another for her money or following the advice of friends or family. In 18 the the lover comes to the wedding and outshines the bride, who kills her through jealousy and is herself killed by the lover, who then kills himself. In 19 the bridegroom in his marriage bed dreams that his true love appears to him. He dresses and rides to her home, to find her dead of a broken heart. He dies of grief and remorse. Both deaths are natural, as also in 20. But in 20 the triangle disappears; the lover is not unfaithful, only laggard, and he returns to find his lady dead of love too long deferred, then himself dies of grief. All three, then, are lovers' tragedies. In 18 there is a triangle with three violent deaths; in 19, there is a triangle, with the two lovers' deaths, neither violent; in 20 the triangle disappears, and the two lovers die without violence, of love-longing and of sorrow. But this analysis the pure forms may be distinguished from there blended texts.
With these three ballads, also, the familiar "rose-and-brier," ending is most frequently associated. Child speaks of this in his introduction to the Douglas Tragedy. As he says, "The beautiful fancy of plants springing from the graves of star-crossed lovers, and signifying by the intertwining of stems or leaves, or, in other analogous ways, that an earthly passion has not been extinguished by death, presents itself as is well known, very frequently in popular poetry. Though the graves be made far apart, even on opposite sides of the church, or one to the north and one south, outside the church, or one without kirk wall and one in the choir, however separated. the vines or trees seek one another out, and mingle their branches or their foliage:
"Even from the tomb the voice of Nature cries,
Even in our ashes live their wonted fires!"
In the Virginia texts, this fanciful idea is seldom found in 18 (see B). but regularly in 19 and 20. And the appendage appears again a little later in the Virginia texts of " Barbara Allen "'(No. 24, which as another love tragedy is also akin to this group.
No. 18 is known in Virginia as "Lord Thomas and Fair Ellinor," "Lord Thomas," "The Brown Girl," "Lord Thomas and the Brown Girl," "The Three Lovers," "Fair Ellen," "Lord Thomas and Fair Ellen," and by other like titles. The simple name Eleanor goes through many changes of spelling and pronunciation, from Ellinor to Ellender. The thirty-seven texts and seven tunes of this ballad collected in Virginia indicate its great, and deserved popularity. Most of the texts are complete or nearly so, and in an excellent state of preservation. But they all seem to be more closely related to the Child D group than to any other version. They follow the English rather than the Scottish form of the ballad.
Several of the Virginia variants begin with a description of Lord Thomas and Fair Eleanor. But in most of the variants, as Cox says of the West Virginia texts, " the story begins by the hero's asking his mother to solve the riddle as to whether he shall marry Fair Eleanor or bring the brown girl home. Since the brown girl has house and lot (land) and Fair Eleanor has none, she advises him to marry the brown girl. Thereupon he dresses himself up in state, takes his merry men with him, rides to Fair Eleanor's hall, and invites her to his wedding on the morrow. She says that it is very bad news to her for she expected to be his bride. Later she asks her mother to solve the riddle as to whether she shall go to Lord Thomas's wedding or stay at home. Her mother advises her to stay at home since she will have few friends at the wedding and many enemies, but she is determined to go. Thereupon she arrays herself in her finery, takes her merry maids with her, and rides to Lord Thomas's hall. In answer to her knocking, Lord Thomas himself lets her in, leads her into the hall, and chooses for her the highest seat. Fair Eleanor twits him with having married such a brown wife, whereupon the brown girl stabs her with a pen-knife between the short ribs and the long. Lord Thomas asks her why she looks so pale and she suggests that he must be blind not to observe her heart's blood trickling down to her knee. With a little hand-sword Lord Thomas cuts off the head of the brown girl, kicks it against the wall, and then slays himself with the same sword. Before he dies, he requests that Fair Eleanor be buried in his arms and the brown girl at his feet." This summary by Cox may stand for the typical Virginia text as well.
American texts of this ballad are very numerous, showing its great popularity in the New World. See Barry,No. 2; Belden, No. 1 (fragment); Brown, p. 9 (North Carolina); Bulletin, Nos. 2,-3, 5-10; Campbell and Sharp, No. 16 (North Carolina, Georgia,-Tennessee, Massachusetts, Virginia); Child, III, 509 (Virginia from The Folk Lore Journal, vol,33, 1889); Cox, No. 10; Hudson, No 10 (and Journal, XXXIX, 94; Mississippi); Journal, XVIII, 128 (Barry, Vermont, text and melody: Massachusetts, fragment), 295 (Barry, Vermont, melody only); XIX, 235, (Belden, Missouri, Arkansas); XX, 254 (Kittredge, Kentucky); XXVIII, 71 (Barry, melody only; XXVIII, 152 (Perrow, North Carolina); XXIX, 159 (Tolman, Pennsylvania, fragment); McGill, p.28; Mackenzie, p. 97 Mackenzie, Ballads, No. 6 and p. 392 (text and melody); Pound, Syllabus, p. 11 (fragment); Pound, Ballads, No. 12; Sandburg, p. 157 (North Carolina); Shearin, p.3; Shearin and Combs, p. 9; Shoemaker, p. 155; Reed Smith, No. 5 (texts and melodies); Reed Smith, Ballads, No. 5; Wyman and Brockway, Songs, p. 14 (Kentucky). For additional references, see Cox, p. 45; Journal, XXIX, 159.
F. "The Three Lovers." Reported by Professor W. A. Montgomery. Sung by Mrs. Olin Fisk Wiley, of Richmond, Va. Wise County, June, 1915.
1 Lord Thomas was a nice young gentleman,
He rode a many a town;
He courted a girl they called fair Eleanor
And one called Sally Brown.
2 "Father and mother, I'll ask you both as one,
Whether I must marry fair Elender,[1]
Or bring the Brown girl home?"
3 "Foes they may be many, Lord Thomas,
The Brown girl she has house and land,
And Fair Elender she has none;
You take the warning by such a kind friend
And bring the Brown girl home."
4 He went up to fair Elender's gate
And loudly he tingled and called;
There was none so ready to let him in
But fair Elender herself.
5. "What have you brought me, Lord Thomas?''said she,
"I've come to invite you to my wedding,
Tomorrow it shall be."
6 " Father and mother, I'll ask you both as one,
Whether I must go to Lord Thomas' wedding
Or whether I must stay at home?"
7 "Foes they may be many, fair Elender,
And friends they may be few;
If you'll take warning of such a kind friend,
You'll stay with your mother at home'"
8 "I care nothing for friends or foes,
But Lord Thomas's wedding I'll go."
9 She dressed herself in silk so fine,
Her waist was diamond green;
And every town that she rode through,
They took her to be some queen.
10 She rode up to Lord Thomas's Hall
And tingled in the ring;
But there was none as ready as Lord Thomas himself
Rising to let her in.
11 He took her by the lily-white hand,
And led her through the Hall,
And sat her down at the head of the table,
Among the ladies all.
12 She said, "Is this your bride, Lord Thomas?
I think she is dreadful brown;
You once could have married as fair a girl
As ever the sun shined on."
13 The Brown girl had a long pen-knife,
The point both keen and sharp,
She put it against fair Elender's breast
And stove it to her heart.
14 Lord Thomas took the Brown girl by the hand,
And led her through the hall,
And took a sword, cut off her head,
And kicked it against the wall.
15 He put the handle against the floor,
The point against his breast:
"This is the end of three true loves;
Lord, send our souls to rest."
16 "Go bury fair Elender in my arms,
The Brown girl at my feet,
And in both hands a glass of wine,
Happy that we all may sleep."
-------------
1 The contributor draws attention to the change of name here.