The House Carpenter- Quarles (VA) 1915 Davis Z
[From Kyle Davis, Jr.'s Traditional Ballads of Virginia, 1929. Davis says in Traditional Ballads of Virginia that "The House Carpenter" is second only to "Barbara Allen" in popularity in Virginia with fifty-two texts and seven musical transcriptions of which twenty-nine texts and seven melodies are given A-AA. Additionally two variants are given as an appendix which have stanzas of the House Carpenter within a related ballad.
R. Matteson 2013]
Traditional Ballads of Virginia (Davis' commentary)
JAMES HARRIS (THE DAEMON LOVER) (Child, No. 243)
Next to "Barbara Allen" in Virginia popularity stands "The House Carpenter," with fifty-two texts and seven melodies, of which twenty-nine-texts and all seven melodies are here given. "The House Carpenter" is its almost invariable title, which yields only once to "The House Carpenter's Wife" (a slightly more appropriate title) and once to "On the Banks of the Sweet Laurie."
"James Harris" which appears once, and "The Daemon Lover," which appears three times at the head of manuscripts (and therefore in the table of contents), may be regarded merely as identifications, not as local titles. The lover has lost not only his name, but also, with the possible exception of four variants, all trace of his demoniac character.
The Virginia texts are most closely related to Child B, but with occasional stanzas and details that suggest other Child versions. But as all the Child versions are based upon A, with traditional modifications, the story of Child A may be profitably scanned as a preliminary step: "Jane Reynolds and James Harris, a seaman, had exchanged vows of marriage. The young man was pressed as a sailor, and after three years was reported as dead; the young woman married a ship carpenter, and they lived together happily for four years, and had children. One night when this carpenter was absent from home, a spirit rapped at the window and announced himself as James Harris, come after an absence of seven years to claim the woman for his wife. She explained the state of things, but upon obtaining assurance that her long-lost lover had the means to support her- seven ships upon the sea - consented to go with him, for he was really much like unto a man. 'The woman-kind' was seen no more after that; the carpenter hanged himself."
The Virginia ballad cuts out all the antecedent action and the aftermath about the carpenter. It omits all names (except for the stolen "Fair Ellen" of Virginia F), and deprives the lover altogether of his ghostly character (with the possible exception of Virginia A, M, N, and Appendix A). The Virginia story, then, is a compressed and very human drama of illicit elopement and retribution. A seaman returns to find his old love married, it seems happily, to a house carpenter, by whom she has a child (or more). By his persuasiveness and by promises, the old lover induces the wife to desert husband and babe and sail away with him. But soon she pines for the old ties, weeps for her sweet little babe, and (sometimes after she has had a vision of the torment in store for her) the ship springs a leak and sinks to the bottom of the sea. There is often a final stanza voicing her contrition, her curse upon deceiving men, or her warning to other women. In Virginia texts the carpenter does not reappear, as he does in Child B, to grieving and swon at the news of the disaster and to curse such deluding mariners. Virginia A, M, N, and appendix A are related to Child E and F; they contain the "hills of heaven and hell" stanzas, in which the so-called lover by interpreting the wife's vision assumes a more eerie and diabolical personality. But she never spies his cloven foot, as in Child E, F, and G, and, even the vision stanzas are exceedingly rare in Virginia.
"The House Carpenter" is very often corrupted with other songs and ballads that fit in with its general motif. But it generally preserves its own identity; it does not, like "The Lass of Roch Royal" in Virginia, merely contribute certain stanzas to other songs of the texts that follow, A-E are more or less pure and unalloyed variants, though the name "Fair Ellen," in F9 and Q4, and stanzas E 8, K 7, N 3, suggest "Lord Thomas and Fair Eleanor." But with R the combined texts begin. R-AA are marked by the intrusion of a stanza or more from some other source, but with the "House Carpenter" story still well preserved. Appendices A and B have been corrupted almost beyond recognition, but they still preserve two or three stanzas of the ballad. The "shoe my foot" stanias of "The Lass of Roch Royal," appear in R 7, and 8, S 7 and 8, Appendix A 5 and 6, Appendix B 5 and 6; and the chorus of Appendix A is a stanza of "The Lass of Roch Royal" seldom found in Virginia. In variants T-AA stanzas are supplied from certain later songs- which have something in common with "The House Carpenter" such as a lovers' greeting, a lovers' parting, a false lover, a remorseful lover, a betrayed lover's lament or warning, -etc. Traces of "The False young Man," "The True Lover's Farewell," "The Rejected Lover," "The Wagoner's Lad," "Cold Winter's Night," "Careless Love," and perhaps other English folk-songs are to be found in the Virginia variants T-AA, and in the appendices. "The False Young Man" is the most frequent intruder. These variants in combination are a most interesting feature of the ballad in Virginia
Z. "The House Carpenter."- Collected by Miss Juliet Fauntleroy. Sung by Miss Daisy Quarles, Rock, Va. Bedford Countv. October 17, 1915. Again the final stanzas 11 ans 12 belong to other songs. Compare Virginia Y preceding, stanzas 12 and 13, and see its head-note.
1 "We have [met], we have [met], my old true love,
I am glad that I have met with thee;
For I am just from the salt water sea
And it is all for the sake of thee.
2 "I could have married a king's daughter fair,
I am sure she would have married me;
It was not for the gold that she possessed,
It was all for the sake of thee."
3 "If you could have married a king's daughter fair,
I'm sure you were to blame;
For I have married a house carpenter,
And I think he is a fine young man."
4 "Oh! won't you forsake your house carpenter
And go a long with me?
I will carry you where the grass grows green
On the edge of sweet Willie."
5 She dressed herself all over in red,
And then she dressed in green,
And as she marched on down the street
She shined as any queen.
6 This lady had not been on the sea two weeks,
I am sure it was not three,
Before she began to weep,
And she wept most bitterly.
7 "Are you weeping for my gold?" said he,
"Are you weeping for my store?
Are you weeping for the house carpenter
Which you never shall see more?"
8 "I neither am weeping for your gold," said she,
"Neither for your store;
I am weeping for the house carpenter
Which I never shall see more."
9 This lady hadn't been on sea three weeks,
I am sure it was not four,
Before the ship it sprang a leak,
And it sank to rise no more.
10 She said, "Cursed be all sailor men!"
She cursed a sailor's life,
Which had robbed her of her rest
And deprived her of her life.
11 I've seen green leaves, all trodden under foot,
To rise up and grow again;
True love is a killing thing;
Did you ever feel the pain?
12 'T is first to love and then to hate
And then to love again;
True love it is a killing thing;
Did you ever feel the pain?